Emre KOCAZEYBEK, Mehmet ERSİN
The Medical Bulletin of Haseki - 2026;64(4):254-263
Aim: The optimal fixation strategy for Lisfranc injuries remains controversial, particularly regarding the choice between Kirschner wire (K-wire) fixation and screw-based open reduction and internal fixation (ORIF). This study aimed to compare the clinical, radiological, and complication-related outcomes of closed reduction and percutaneous pinning (CRPP) and ORIF in the treatment of Lisfranc injuries. Methods: This retrospective comparative study included patients with Lisfranc injuries who were treated with either CRPP using K-wires or ORIF using screws. Demographic characteristics, injury patterns, and operative details were recorded. Functional outcomes were assessed using the American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society (AOFAS) midfoot score, the foot and ankle ability measure- activities of daily living (FAAM-ADL), and the maryland foot score. Radiological evaluation included measurements of intermetatarsal and intercuneiform alignment, dorsal step-off, and tarsometatarsal joint congruity. Postoperative complications and the need for secondary arthrodesis were also analyzed. Results: A total of 37 patients were included (CRPP: n=17; ORIF: n=20). Patients treated with ORIF demonstrated significantly higher functional scores, including the AOFAS, FAAM-ADL, and Maryland scores, compared with those in the CRPP group (p=0.001). Radiological assessment revealed better maintenance of alignment and a significantly lower dorsal step-off in the ORIF group. Overall complication rates did not differ significantly between groups. However, secondary arthrodesis was more frequently required following CRPP , whereas implant-related events and sensory disturbances tended to occur more often after ORIF , without reaching statistical significance. Conclusion: Open reduction and internal fixation provided superior functional outcomes and better maintenance of midfoot alignment compared with CRPP . While K-wire fixation may be considered when ORIF is not feasible, rigid fixation with ORIF appears to offer a more reliable restoration of midfoot stability.